Value based care as practiced is impossible to practice ethically. If a patient is given all reasonable options, and chooses the most expensive that may not be the most effective but has the fewer quality of life side effects, who pays for that choice? The surgeon?
Paying physicians fee-for-service ensures access, especially for procedural care. It aligns incentives the same way every other service-based industry does. Want a plumber, electrician, lawyer, coder? You pay for the service rendered. Simple. Transparent. Effective. Naturally emerging alternatives like DPC can work well because they’re voluntary and market-driven. No central bureaucrat mandated it. But top-down “value-based” payment models are a bureaucratic fantasy. They add layers of documentation, create perverse incentives to game metrics, and shift focus from caring for patients to pleasing administrators. The problem isn’t FFS. It’s the central planners who think they can outsmart price signals and redesign medicine with spreadsheets and buzzwords.
3
2
18
7,600
Alex Shteynshlyuger MD retweeted
Since 2015, the UN has passed 188 resolutions condemning Israel. That's more than twice as many as against the rest of the world combined—Russia, China, Iran, and Venezuela included. Yet diplomats sat politely through a speech from Iran, a regime that has killed thousands of its own citizens and still persecutes them. It's not about human rights. It's blatant anti-Israel bias.
"If there are any other moral cowards who haven't yet left this hall, please do so now." ⠀ Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu opens his address to the United Nations General Assembly in New York with a sharp rebuke as delegates walk out of the hall in protest of his speech.
1,486
1,941
9,715
250,698
Alex Shteynshlyuger MD retweeted
Our men are struggling—and the numbers demand our attention.   50% of men have hypertension.
39% are living with obesity.
Heart disease and cancer account for 43% of male deaths.
And men represent 80% of suicide deaths.   These aren’t just statistics. They represent fathers, sons, brothers, husbands, friends, and communities. I’m encouraged to see @UCLA recognizing the urgency of men’s health and taking action to address it. Improving the health of men strengthens families and communities and it’s time we give this challenge the attention it deserves.
2
3
20
1,310
RT @4ILorg: The UN rewrite the Truth

​

govextra.gov.il
151
3
Alex Shteynshlyuger MD retweeted
Drugmakers invest more than $100 billion in R&D each year to develop new treatments and cures. Meanwhile, the FTC found that PBMs mark up some generic drugs by hundreds or even thousands of percent. Lawmakers looking to lower drug costs should start there.
NEW: Analysis found that Big Pharma spends 3x more on profits, advertising and corporate overhead than they invest in R&D. More:
3
7
323
What genocidal regime gives a million polio vaccinations to the enemy's population? What genocidal regime enables the distribution of 2 million tons of food into Gaza? That's a tonne for every person. Accusing Israel of genocide is the greatest lie of the century!
4,021
11,306
56,562
944,998
Alex Shteynshlyuger MD retweeted
🧐 The new Linked Discoveries tool accessible through PubMed seeks to help scientists explore how individual research findings relate to the larger body of biomedical evidence. It is a direct reflection of our agency’s commitment to strengthening replication and reproducibility in NIH-funded research.
NEWS: NIH launches new resource accessible through PubMed to strengthen research replication and reproducibility. Read the full story ➡️ bit.ly/4y7rXtA
10
18
149
19,774
US "think tanks" argue deregulating NPs will fix our $2.7T healthcare crisis by lowering costs. But, look at the UK. The BMA just dropped a dossier linking doctor-substitution to severe patient harm & deaths. Cutting corners on medical standards isn't a solution.
‘A real threat to patient safety.’ As @TheBMA releases a report cataloguing hundreds of doctors’ concerns about the use of advanced practitioner (AP) staff, association chair @thomasdolphin calls on NHS leaders to wake up and take action. 🧵[1/6] thedoctor.bma.org.uk/article…
10
15
88
11,602
Here's an interesting discussion & related to this: 27 states have passed laws for international doctors to bypass or "skip" repeating a traditional U.S. residency. Isn't the reliance on foreign doctors a byproduct of an artificial scarcity of medical school & residency spots?
🚨 Wow. Apparently all but one of Parkview Health’s new class of internal medicine residents in Indiana are foreigners here on J-1 visas. America should do whatever it takes to recruit and train Americans for these critical jobs not rely on imported labor
4
4
20
3,937
Alex Shteynshlyuger MD retweeted
I hope people realize that for the foreseeable future, the cost of healthcare benefits will get more people fired, or not hired, than AI
726
810
9,491
1,097,460
So basically, you are promoting complete consolidation of the market with ONLY one negotiation that is possible: Hospital + Insurance companies. We know how it has been working out between the two of them - >15% year-to-year growth in costs? Force all physicians into complete dependency on hospitals; give hospitals "tyrannical" power over physicians. Essentially, make employed + non-employed physicians equally dependent on hospital largesse. Remove ANY incentive for health insurance to negotiate fair rates directly with physicians. We see where it's going - not a free market but Monopoly on hospital + physician services + Monopsony on insurer side. Instead of negotiating a fair compensation, you want to "force" physicians to sign whatever contract @UHC and @AnthemBCBS puts in front of their nose, often without even the right to read the contract. You know well that there are no negotiatons and that's why 80% of physicians are "employed." Brilliant idea. Brookings institution is truly a "think tank" but it can think only "one step" at a time. Oblivious to unintended consequences.
Good write-up of some of the issues with the No Surprises Act and how to fix them. For non-emergency services, in particular, the contract regulation approach they outline continues to offer a number of advantages. cato.org/regulation/fall-202…
9
5
33
3,430
Alex Shteynshlyuger MD retweeted
Replying to @KeenanPeachy
NY teachers who can't pass literacy tests.
Never forget that in New York they eliminated the literacy exam in 2017. And this exam wasn't for students - it was the literacy exam for TEACHERS. Only 61% could pass it!
4
34
393
12,885
Insurance company accounting’s is basically “funny money.” The posted loss is 0.5% of revenue. They can dial it up next quarter to 20% profit by simply denying 10% more claims, prior authorizations, and appeals. Who can stop them?
I do see a forthcoming trend where more health plans could declare bankruptcy. Watching this closely.
1
1
3
660
Alex Shteynshlyuger MD retweeted
Nicole Hannah-Jones and @nytimes did not disclose that her husband, Faraji Hannah-Jones, sits on the. 24-member Panel for Educational Policy, and chairs the contracts commitee, which oversees millions of dollars spent by the city Department of Education. schools.nyc.gov/get-involved…
59
511
3,447
212,439
If the @ERISAIndCmte want to deliver documents electronically, it must be mandated to receive them electronically. Must publish publicly electronic delivery address for each plan. @USDOL @DrOzCMS @DrOzCMS
ERIC and partners urge DOL to finalize default e-delivery for health plan communications and extend it to all ERISA welfare plans. James Gelfand: the proposal "takes the important step of modernizing outdated regulations." Read press release here: bit.ly/4rpmP1v
1
1
1
220
>15 years of doing penile implants, and apparently @MetroPlusHealth knows something about penile implants that I don't. "Cortisol...can affect how well a penile implant may work." and now a "necessary" test to do before they approve a penile implant. Of course, the patient has no history of cortisol-related pathology...some algorithm.... Can someone explain to me - what is the evidence that cortisol levels are "medically necessary", and why we don't have them in the @AmerUrological guidelines or on the Board Exam?🤣 Maybe @AHIPCoverage can help with the answer? @justindubinmd @ABUrology @DrPaulPerito @RepGregMurphy @rachelcohrs @SMSNA_ORG
4
3
20
17,351
I think eventually, it will come not to transcription but the recording itself as the record of the visit.
“Can I have a copy of the transcription?” The answer is actually no
1
1
9
4,775
Alex Shteynshlyuger MD retweeted
Replying to @j_g_allen
Appreciate your POV. However, the NIH has drifted into the business of funding politically-motivated social science and pseudoscience over the past 10-20 years. No one objects to funding real pure science. If the system is not reformed, we will be back here again and public support for the NIH will fall.
3
2
14
771
Alex Shteynshlyuger MD retweeted
Also, the hospital-complication studies they love to cite examined PE owned nursing homes and hospitals. These are NOT physician practices. But @SenWarren proposed bill explicitly exempts hospitals and hospital-affiliated clinics from its corporate-ownership prohibition while imposing that restriction on physician practices. That is precisely the regulatory favoritism I’m criticizing. None of which people like @DGlaucomflecken speak to…
I, also, suspect the hospital lobby and large health systems love the proposed corporate practice of medicine ban. It reinforces the regulatory favoritism they already benefit from. Despite what @DGlaucomflecken implies… MSOs are used by private equity AND by independent physicians. For independent practices, they allow practices to pool resources, share administrative services and reduce overhead. This is critical for many independent practices in the current environment. No, the bill doesn’t ban MSOs outright. But, It does restrict their contracts and management relationships, with no blanket exemption for physician owned MSOs. Requirements for independent advisers and fair market value compensation add compliance obligations. Meanwhile, hospitals and hospital affiliated clinics are exempt from the core ownership prohibition. Honestly, they are exempt from many of the regulations that apply to physicians. To be clear, I don’t have an issue with people who object to private equity owning medical practices. My objection is to leveraging the corporate boogie man to restrict a tool physicians also use to remain independent while preserving the hospital ownership pathway. The predictable consequence is more legal expense, more compliance risk and greater difficulty operating an independent practice. That gives hospitals another competitive advantage, packaged as protection for physician independence.
3
8
45
1,883
Fundamentally, the problem is that most patients have no control of the money they earn used to pay for their health insurance and little appreciation of how much it costs. Regulation stands in the way of innovation. What I can do in the office is not paid enough to cover my costs but reimbursed at 300% more in a surgical center.
Innovation, Prices, and Centralized Forecasts "Prices are signals. They tell suppliers whether to enter, expand, invest, open a new site, adopt a new tool, run a trial, or develop a future treatment. Payment rules therefore become production rules. A lower price produced through competition is a supply-side achievement. It means entry, productivity, innovation, lower-cost sites, or better organization have reduced the real resources required to deliver care. A lower price imposed by command is different. It can reduce the posted price while making supply less attractive, which can lead to exit, shortages, delayed innovation, quality tradeoffs, or budget-window savings that reappear later as less care or less innovation. This distinction matters because many health-care price controls are largely invisible to patients. DRG rates, CPT-based physician fee schedules, Part B reimbursement, and IRA drug price controls do more than move money among payers and providers. They shape capacity, sites of care, investment decisions, quality, and the future supply of treatments. Affordability requires lower real resource costs, not merely lower displayed prices. The danger of centralized supply control is that one forecast can become a national rule." Full ASPE Report "Producing Health: Capability, Capacity, and Competitive Discovery in the Health Economy," by HHS Chief Economist and Chief Regulatory Officer Dr. Casey B. Mulligan: aspe.hhs.gov/reports/produci… @HHSGov @CMSGov @HHSResponse @HHS_ASPE
1
2
5
926